20/05/01 17:12:44 +dY6hOLd.net
(woitブログ 要点抜粋)
URLリンク(www.math.columbia.edu)
Not Even Wrong
Latest on abc
Posted on April 3, 2020 by woit
(抜粋)
1)4月3日の発表にびっくり
Peter Scholze says:
April 6, 2020 at 9:28 am
I have been weighing back and forth commenting again on this matter. However, the news in that last comment by David J. Littleboy convinced me that it might be good, even if futile, to say something again.
I may have not expressed this clearly enough in my manuscript with Stix, but there is just no way that anything like what Mochizuki does can work.
2)joshi氏:改訂版はScholze氏にも見てもらう
kirti joshi says:
April 8, 2020 at 10:15 am
In our correspondence Scholze has agreed (mostly) with all the changes in the new version and we (i.e. Scholze, Hoshi and myself) continue to correspond to resolve any persisting issues (of which there are very few).
3)IUTのthe current version見た(いまさらながら)
Peter Scholze says:
April 15, 2020 at 4:31 pm
Dear Taylor,
First half: I was refering to the current version on his webpage. I realize that this is dangerous, but it’s the only thing that at least currently makes it possible for everyone to follow.
4)(望月の)”his notation is famously forbidding”
Peter Scholze says:
April 17, 2020 at 7:15 pm
PS: I just realized that maybe the following information is worth sharing.
Namely, as an outsider one may wonder that the questions being discussed at length in these comments (e.g., the issue of distinct copies etc.) are very far from the extremely intricate definitions in Mochizuki’s manuscripts
(his notation is famously forbidding, some of it surfaced in Taylor’s comments),
and feel almost philosophical, so one might wonder that one is not looking at the heart of the matter.
5)議論は、まだ進行中(^^;